Human meals linked diseases and pet meals linked diseases are each reported to FDA. Human meals (and complement) hostile occasions are reported to FDA by way of the company’s Human Meals Grievance System. All reviews are publicly out there for shoppers to view.
Pet diseases linked to pet meals and treats are reported to FDA by way of the Security Reporting Portal. Not one of the reviews are publicly out there.
Each human sickness linked to human meals and pet sickness linked to pet meals are recognized to be under-reported. The CDC estimates (in reference to human meals/human sickness), that “foodborne Salmonella causes 29 diseases for every case that’s detected by way of laboratory testing.” In different phrases, for human diseases linked to human meals, it’s believed that just one in 29 circumstances are reported to FDA.
We are able to safely assume related under-reporting happens in pet meals.
In 2024, the FDA acquired an estimated 2,300 human sickness reviews linked to human meals (primarily based on information from FDA Human Meals Grievance System, sorted for meals reviews).
With an estimated 340 million folks within the US, because of this an estimated 1 in 148,000 folks reported a human meals linked sickness to FDA.
In contrast to with human meals reported diseases that are offered publicly on the FDA web site, pet meals reported diseases can solely be obtained by way of a Freedom of Info Act request (which requires ready months to years to obtain). Primarily based on the FOIA paperwork Kohl Harrington (Pet Fooled) and TruthaboutPetFood.com has acquired, an estimated 2700 pet sickness reviews linked to pet meals had been reported to FDA in 2024.
With an estimated 160 million cats and canines within the US, because of this an estimated 1 in 59,000 pets had been reported to FDA unwell in 2024 linked to pet meals.
Human sickness linked to human meals reported: 1 report per 148,000 folks.
Pet sickness linked to pet meals reported: 1 report per 59,000 pets.
That may be a vital distinction. Reported diseases of pets from pet meals had been virtually 3 instances greater than reported diseases of individuals from human meals.
Nearly 3 instances extra. Why?
Maybe the reason being security requirements for (most) pet meals are considerably decrease than human meals security requirements. Equivalent to when a Mars Petcare facility was discovered throughout FDA inspection to have “tens of millions of roaches” within the manufacturing space but FDA took no motion in opposition to the corporate. ‘Tens of millions of roaches’ gave the impression to be a suitable manufacturing customary for pet meals (primarily based on FDA’s lack of motion).
Maybe the FDA’s allowance of unlawful per federal regulation components – resembling meats or meat meals sourced from diseased animals and animals which have died aside from by slaughter – into pet meals is linked to reported pet diseases being virtually 3 instances extra doubtless. Such because the bloated decomposing hog carcasses at Darling Components in Denver, CO witnessed by a pet proprietor – ready to be floor, cooked, and offered to pet house owners with out label disclosure.
As properly, maybe the rationale pet meals are virtually 3 instances as more likely to trigger a reported hostile occasion is linked to the non-disclosure of using unlawful components and deceptive labeled pet meals. How can pet house owners keep away from probably excessive danger components if they aren’t required to be disclosed?
May it’s…that if pet meals was required to abide by present federal and state legal guidelines – as an alternative of being allowed to violate federal and state legal guidelines by FDA and State regulatory authorities – there can be considerably much less sick pets?
Private opinion: I firmly consider so.
Susan ThixtonPet Meals Security AdvocateAuthor Purchaser Beware, Co-Writer Dinner PAWsibleTruthaboutPetFood.comAssociation for Reality in Pet Meals
Discover Wholesome Pet Meals in Your Space Click on Right here
The 2026 ListOur trusted ‘checklist’ of pet meals. Click on Right here to be taught extra.
The 2025/26 Deal with ListSusan’s Record of trusted pet deal with producers. Click on Right here to be taught extra.
Affiliation for Reality in Pet Meals is a stakeholder group representing pet meals shoppers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend conferences and voice shopper considerations with regulatory authorities. Click on Right here to be taught extra.
