To start out issues off on shaky floor, the AAFCO official agenda included a gathering notification of an business commerce group.
The AFIA assembly – an business commerce affiliation assembly – ought to NOT have been listed in a regulatory assembly agenda.
AAFCO is an unbiased group whose members are state feed officers, authorities workers. The work accomplished by AAFCO ends in state legal guidelines that govern pet meals and animal feed. AFIA alternatively is a commerce affiliation, representing the desires and desires of business. Whereas these two organizations actually work collectively, there must be a really strong line separating the 2 organizations. Every group has a foundational distinction in what they do and who they characterize. When AAFCO blurs that line between business and regulatory by itemizing an business assembly on the agenda for a regulatory assembly – belief in AAFCO suffers. It makes you query what different ‘issues’ AAFCO is doing as favors for business?
Although FDA and AAFCO not work collectively as they did prior to now, FDA nonetheless attends these conferences. AAFCO said 36 FDA representatives had been in attendance.
FDA previously supplied the scientific evaluation of latest animal feed/pet meals components. Now, FDA has a separate animal feed/pet meals ingredient approval course of from AAFCO’s. In a dialogue relating to AAFCO’s ingredient approval course of, a state feed official from Texas shared his state’s legal guidelines require a ‘threat evaluation’ for every new animal feed ingredient, he said AAFCO’s ingredient approval course of doesn’t embrace threat evaluation. AAFCO responded sharing their ingredient approval course of contains ‘security knowledge’ for every new ingredient. Is there a distinction between a ‘threat evaluation’ and ‘security knowledge’? AAFCO didn’t assume so, AAFCO felt they had been the identical factor. Texas didn’t agree.
In a dialogue on doubtlessly enhancing the definitions of meat and bone meal and meat meal, the disclosure was made that meat meals usually include 28% ash. Ash content material is an indicator of how a lot bone is included, and represents the mineral content material of an ingredient (or pet meals). It was additionally disclosed that meat and bone meal components could be as excessive as 45% ash.
The keynote speaker at this assembly was Michael Johnson of BSM Companions – a pet meals business consulting agency. Whereas Mr. Johnson gave an excellent presentation, made some good factors – he did so by being considerably insulting to pet meals shoppers.
He gave the instance that folks drive a automobile with out understanding precisely how the brakes work, however pet house owners name producers of pet meals demanding to understand how lengthy the pet meals was cooked and at what temperature. He wasn’t deliberately attempting to belittle pet house owners (though he stored repeating ‘pet house owners are bizarre’), however at instances it was clear he didn’t have the understanding of pet house owners desires and desires (regardless that he thought he did).
He did accurately emphasize that pet house owners need to have the ability to belief their pet meals, it’s security. And he additionally accurately identified to AAFCO that pet house owners need to perceive and belief their regulators.
We see the issue of belief in pet meals security just a little in a different way. Utilizing Mr. Johnson’s analogy, individuals who drive vehicles won’t perceive precisely how the brakes work, however they do know the legal guidelines of the highway. In evaluating this to pet meals shoppers, pet house owners have been denied public entry to the highway guidelines (as a result of AAFCO owns and copyright protects the laws). Are you able to think about driving a automobile with none information of the highway guidelines? Contemplating that each single ingredient in pet meals has its personal distinctive definition that’s usually dramatically completely different from the identical ingredient in human meals…take into consideration driving that automobile when one time a STOP signal means cease, and within the subsequent block the STOP signal means go. And the motive force of the automobile isn’t instructed which is which.
Now you’re getting nearer to understanding what pet house owners need to undergo to belief their pet meals. Don’t blame pet house owners for asking questions, attempting to study the highway guidelines.
Throughout the Ingredient Definitions Committee Assembly, a proposed description of the time period HPP was mentioned. The next is barely a draft definition, it’s nonetheless in dialogue.
“Excessive Strain Pasteurization (Course of). A non-thermal preservation approach that inactivates microorganisms via the applying of intense stress. When correctly utilized, the method can obtain a minimum of a 6-log discount of related pathogens. The producer should validate the pathogen-reduction efficiency of the method for his or her particular product matrix and should doc the parameters essential to persistently obtain the validated 6-log discount.”
There was a lot dialogue on this description of HPP, together with from FDA who didn’t need the phrase ‘Pasteurization’ used, they most popular ‘Processing’. This dialogue went down a rabbit gap into defining what ‘sluggish cooked’ means and different labeling phrases. Some felt these phrases shouldn’t be outlined (similar to sluggish cooked), others felt they need to. We must look ahead to future conferences to see the place this lands.
Throughout the Pet Meals Committee assembly, a presentation was supplied by Dr. Claire Timlin, of 4 Rivers Kennels (a laboratory kennel that partly performs feeding trials). She supplied analysis to AAFCO – each analysis from the 4 Rivers Kennels and revealed analysis – evidencing the dietary wants of senior pets (her presentation’s emphasis was on canine). As instance, she supplied analysis evidencing {that a} senior canine wants 1.5 instances the quantity of protein than an grownup canine. She confirmed proof that pet meals labeled for senior canine different dramatically in protein quantities – emphasizing the necessity for AAFCO to take some sort of motion to guard senior pets from doubtlessly deceptive advertising. And she or he instructed that analysis exhibits nutrient profiles (the dietary necessities) for senior pets ought to be altered in a method that seniors get much less energy whereas nonetheless receiving the entire required vitamins.
Two issues…
Europe has had for a number of years particular dietary profiles for much less energetic pets (similar to senior pets). European pet meals have the power to formulate a pet meals that comprises much less energy to satisfy the wants of much less energetic pets (similar to senior pets) whereas nonetheless offering all vitamins to these pets. However not right here within the US.
That is EXACTLY what Steve Brown, Dr. Karen Becker, and myself introduced to FDA a number of years in the past (the issue of much less energetic pets dietary profiles). Though we clearly evidenced the necessity, our plea for motion fell on deaf ears. FDA did nothing.
It appeared AAFCO was prepared to open the door to doubtlessly defining a nutrient profile particular to senior pets, however then FDA shut it down. One FDA consultant brazenly said she wasn’t positive a dietary profile to learn senior pets/much less energetic pets was needed.
They did agree to speak about it extra, type a working group to speak about (ONLY speak about) what they need to do sooner or later. Which most likely delays what’s presently wanted in US pet meals for a number of years.
Private opinion: Whereas Europe progressively strikes ahead updating their nutrient profiles, AAFCO and FDA stays stagnant – virtually making the prevailing US pet meals laws out of date. Our pets do NOT profit from stagnant determination makers/out of date laws, however business advantages drastically promoting deceptive claims to unknowing pet house owners with no laws to cease them.
Susan ThixtonPet Meals Security AdvocateAuthor Purchaser Beware, Co-Creator Dinner PAWsibleTruthaboutPetFood.comAssociation for Fact in Pet Meals
Discover Wholesome Pet Meals in Your Space Click on Right here
The 2026 ListOur trusted ‘record’ of pet meals. Click on Right here to study extra.
The 2025/26 Deal with ListSusan’s Record of trusted pet deal with producers. Click on Right here to study extra.
Affiliation for Fact in Pet Meals is a stakeholder group representing pet meals shoppers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend conferences and voice shopper considerations with regulatory authorities. Click on Right here to study extra.
