Not too long ago, the Heart for Science within the Public Curiosity (CSPI) printed an article titled “Can Pet Meals Make You Sick? Right here’s Find out how to Keep Protected”. The article was disappointing, at greatest.
The creator begins off stating “Pet meals isn’t only a danger for pets. It may well additionally expose folks to dangerous micro organism.” True…however…
The creator then factors fingers at one type of pet meals they declare is the riskiest. “Uncooked pet meals poses the best danger.”
“Uncooked pet diets are sometimes marketed as extra ‘pure,’ however they carry the next danger of dangerous micro organism.”
They base this declare on a examine carried out by the FDA from October 2010 by means of July 2012.
“In a two-year examine, the FDA’s Heart for Veterinary Medication examined greater than 1,000 pet meals samples, and uncooked canine and cat meals stood out. Of 196 uncooked pet meals samples, 15 examined optimistic for salmonella and 32 examined optimistic for listeria. By comparability, only one dry cat meals pattern examined optimistic for salmonella.”
However…the info concerning the danger of dangerous micro organism in pet meals tells a really completely different story. Throughout the timeframe of the FDA testing (2012) the place the company claims it solely discovered “one dry cat meals pattern” examined optimistic for Salmonella, Diamond Pet Meals recalled greater than 60 million kilos of dry pet meals for Salmonellla contamination. This dry pet meals recall resulted in 49 human diseases, 10 people have been hospitalized.
In late 2023, a dry pet meals recall from Mid America Pet Meals resulted in 7 human diseases and 1 hospitalization. The FDA Enforcement Report said 9,508,943 baggage of pet meals have been recalled, an estimated 190,303,860 kilos.
Has the CDC confirmed any human sickness to uncooked pet meals?
The ONLY point out of human sickness linked to uncooked pet meals on the CDC web site is with the 2017 – 2019 outbreak of Salmonella linked to uncooked turkey merchandise (not solely turkey pet meals). The CDC web site states: “Amongst 198 interviewed sufferers, 132 (67%) reported direct or oblique contact with turkey within the week earlier than sickness; 123 reported making ready or consuming turkey merchandise that have been bought uncooked (together with entire turkey, turkey items, and floor turkey), 4 turned sick after pets of their residence ate uncooked floor turkey pet meals, and 5 labored in a facility that raises or processes turkeys or lived with somebody who labored in such a facility. No widespread kind, model, or supply of turkey was recognized.”
Though 4 folks turned sick linked to “uncooked floor turkey pet meals”, the CDC web site doesn’t make clear if the pet meals was a business pet meals or residence ready.
Complete human sickness linked to pet meals:
Kibble = 56 folks, 93% of all pathogenic micro organism human diseases linked to pet meals.
Uncooked = 4 folks, 6% of all pathogenic micro organism human diseases linked to pet meals.
Complete Kilos Recalled
From January 2012 by means of December 2025 – 352,712,936 kilos of pet meals has been recalled for pathogenic micro organism. Of those kilos of pet meals recalled for pathogenic micro organism – 98.6% was for kibble pet meals. Uncooked pet meals alternatively was liable for 0.59% of the full kilos recalled for pathogenic micro organism.
The breakdown of those 352 million recalled kilos of pet meals per type:
Does this appear like uncooked pet meals merchandise “carry the next danger of dangerous micro organism” because the CSPI states?
Disgrace on you Heart for Science within the Public Curiosity. Your story misleads the pet proudly owning public maybe into complacency when dealing with kibble pet meals. Very disappointing.
(We despatched an e mail to the CSPI expressing our disappointment on this story, however we now have not acquired a reply.)
Susan ThixtonPet Meals Shopper AdvocateTruthaboutPetFood.comAssociation for Reality in Pet Meals
Discover Wholesome Pet Meals in Your Space Click on Right here
The 2026 ListOur trusted ‘record’ of pet meals. Click on Right here to study extra.
The 2025/26 Deal with ListSusan’s Checklist of trusted pet deal with producers. Click on Right here to study extra.
Affiliation for Reality in Pet Meals is a stakeholder group representing pet meals customers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend conferences and voice client considerations with regulatory authorities. Click on Right here to study extra.
