From ClassAction.org “A proposed class motion lawsuit alleges that Mars Petcare US, Inc. has falsely marketed its Nutro Pure Alternative canine meals as containing ‘No Synthetic Flavors, Colours, or Preservatives’ when, in actuality, the merchandise include synthetic preservatives.”
From the lawsuit criticism: “The Merchandise’ labels prominently characterize that they include ‘No Synthetic Flavors, Colours, or Preservatives’”:
“This illustration is fake. Nutro Pure Alternative canine meals include each citricacid and combined tocopherols. Citric acid and tocopherols are each synthetic preservatives.”
“Whereas there’s a pure type of citric acid extracted from fruit, this isn’t the formused by Nutro within the Merchandise. It is because ‘[a]proximately 99% of the world’s manufacturing of [citric acid] is carried out utilizing the fungus Aspergillus niger since 1919,’ and the usage of naturally produced citric acid in business meals is prohibitively costly.”
“Nearly all citric acid utilized in U.S. business meals—together with that utilized in theProducts—is produced by a multi-step industrial manufacturing course of, not by extraction from any pure supply.”
The lawsuit explains the commercial manufacturing strategy of citric acid:
“The fashionable citric-acid course of begins with glucose (usually derived fromgenetically modified corn) which is fermented with the commercial mildew Aspergillus niger in large-scale bioreactors. The ensuing fermentation liquor is then chemically precipitated with calcium hydroxide to kind calcium citrate, which is subsequently reacidulated with sulfuric acid and crystallized into refined citric acid. Chemical solvents reminiscent of n-octyl alcohol and artificial isoparaffinic petroleum hydrocarbons are used to extract the citric acid from the A. niger fermentation liquor, and regularly survive the reacidulation course of in fragmentary kind.”
“These steps—microbial fermentation, chemical precipitation, and acid-basereacidulation—are traditional hallmarks of artificial manufacture, not pure derivation. The citric acid within the Merchandise meets this definition exactly: it isn’t extracted from fruit or any pure materials however is manufactured from industrial feedstocks utilizing fermentation and chemical processing. Affordable customers wouldn’t perceive components derived from these processes as ‘pure.’”
The lawsuit additionally claims “The Tocopherols Within the Merchandise Are An Synthetic Preservative”.
“D-alpha tocopherol is a pure tocopherol, usually derived from vegetable oilssuch as soybean, sunflower, rapeseed, or wheat germ oil.”
“In contrast, dl-alpha tocopherol is an artificial tocopherol derived frompetrochemical sources. Its manufacturing course of entails the synthesis oftrimethylhydroquinone (TMHQ) and isopropyl, that are each sourced from petrochemical feedstocks reminiscent of acetone, phenol, and isobutylene.”
“There’s a substantial price distinction between the 2: pure d-alpha tocopherolscost between half once more, to twice as a lot per kilogram as artificial dl-alpha tocopherols. This worth distinction displays variations between the 2 types as to ease of manufacture and the value of substrates.”
“Reflecting this price distinction, just about not one of the tocopherols used as apreservative in pet meals is pure d-alpha tocopherol. Nearly all of those tocopherols are artificial dl-alpha tocopherols.”
As a result of many alternative pet meals embody citric acid and tocopherols and make related ‘No Preservatives’ label claims, we assume there are fairly a number of producers carefully watching this lawsuit.
Click on Right here to learn the complete lawsuit.
Susan ThixtonPet Meals Security AdvocateAuthor Purchaser Beware, Co-Writer Dinner PAWsibleTruthaboutPetFood.comAssociation for Reality in Pet Meals
Discover Wholesome Pet Meals in Your Space Click on Right here
The 2026 ListOur trusted ‘listing’ of pet meals. Click on Right here to be taught extra.
The 2025/26 Deal with ListSusan’s Record of trusted pet deal with producers. Click on Right here to be taught extra.
Affiliation for Reality in Pet Meals is a stakeholder group representing pet meals customers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend conferences and voice shopper issues with regulatory authorities. Click on Right here to be taught extra.
