A brand new White Paper, “Uncooked Security: Mitigating the 20x FDA Recall Threat of Contemporary Pet Meals“, was not too long ago revealed in an business web site, written by a meals irradiation firm. As a result of many deceptive statements made within the paper, we assume it was revealed to scare pet homeowners so badly they might be open to having a uncooked pet meals handled with irradiation.
Probably the most regarding assertion within the White Paper is that this: “Uncooked Pet Meals Are 20x Extra Doubtless To Be Recalled.”
To make their stunning declare, the White Paper lumps pet meals into two fashion classes; uncooked and non-raw.
We did the identical factor. All the information we offer right here is segmented into the identical two classes of pet meals – uncooked and non-raw.
Concerning this stunning declare “Uncooked Pet Meals Are 20x Extra Doubtless To Be Recalled”, the Irradiation Trade White Paper states that “regardless of being < 10% of the market they’re chargeable for ~67% of recollects, making uncooked pet meals over 20x as more likely to be contaminated with pathogens as in comparison with non-raw pet meals.”
Nevertheless, contemplating market share or not contemplating market share – regardless of how we tried to calculate it, we couldn’t decide how they arrived at their stunning ’20x’ declare concerning the chance of uncooked pet meals.
Based mostly on FDA recall information – variety of recall incidents – and particular to pathogenic micro organism recollects from 2018 by 2025:
Non-raw recollects – 42%.Uncooked recollects – 58%.
Positively NOT 20x extra.
The deceptive White Paper discusses the variety of recall incidents solely. Nevertheless, recollects can fluctuate in measurement (kilos recalled) dramatically.
As instance, in 2022 Primal Pet Meals issued a recall (uncooked pet meals) for Listeria. This one explicit recall concerned 2,376 kilos of pet meals.
As in comparison with…in 2021 Midwestern Pet Meals issued a recall (dry pet meals) for Salmonella. This one explicit recall concerned 6,509,819 kilos of pet meals.
No doubt, six million kilos of contaminated pet meals can pose the next danger than two thousand kilos of contaminated pet meals. No matter the reason for a recall, extra kilos of pet meals recalled equals extra potential publicity to pets and folks. Basing a stunning and business damaging declare on the variety of recollects with out disclosing the precise variety of kilos of pet meals concerned in every recall is deceptive.
Based mostly on the FDA Enforcement Studies, now we have been documenting and totaling kilos for every pet meals recall since 2012.
After we whole the kilos of pet meals recalled for pathogenic micro organism over the identical time-frame the white paper referenced – it tells a really totally different story.
Based mostly on kilos recalled from 2018 by 2025 for pathogenic micro organism:Non-raw: 8,478,207 kilos of pet meals recalled for pathogenic micro organism had been non-raw.Uncooked: 1,512,655 kilos of pet meals recalled for pathogenic micro organism had been uncooked.
When taking a look at the entire causes of recollects from 2018 by 2025 in kilos, once more it tells a unique story.
Based mostly on FDA Enforcement Report information, greater than 173 million kilos of non-raw pet meals had been recalled from 2018 by 2025, with only one.5 million kilos of uncooked pet meals recalled.
Whereas irradiation may sterilize a pet meals sufficiently to forestall pathogenic micro organism recollects, irradiation can not stop the next non-raw pet meals recall considerations that we skilled over the previous 8 years.
From 2018 by 2025.
Kilos of pet meals recalled for extra or inadequate nutritional vitamins or minerals, the biggest instance on this time-frame was for extra vitamin D which resulted in lots of pet deaths:
Kilos of pet meals recalled for aflatoxin contamination which resulted in lots of pet deaths:
Kilos of pet meals recalled for pentobarbital contamination (the drug used to euthanize animals):
This irradiation business White Paper wants to completely clarify their math, totally clarify how they made the stunning (and damaging declare) “Uncooked Pet Meals Are 20x Extra Doubtless To Be Recalled.”
In addition they declare within the Paper “2025 Is the Highest Variety of Preventable Pet Meals & Deal with Remembers, Ever”. Once more, we can not clarify their math. In 2025, a complete of 166,071 kilos of pet meals and treats had been recalled. Far decrease than many different years.
Is that this Irradiation Firm making an attempt to shock/scare pet homeowners into trusting irradiated uncooked pet meals? Would you buy an irradiated uncooked pet meals?
Susan ThixtonPet Meals Security AdvocateAuthor Purchaser Beware, Co-Writer Dinner PAWsibleTruthaboutPetFood.comAssociation for Reality in Pet Meals
Discover Wholesome Pet Meals in Your Space Click on Right here
The 2026 ListOur trusted ‘record’ of pet meals. Click on Right here to study extra.
The 2025/26 Deal with ListSusan’s Checklist of trusted pet deal with producers. Click on Right here to study extra.
Affiliation for Reality in Pet Meals is a stakeholder group representing pet meals customers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend conferences and voice shopper considerations with regulatory authorities. Click on Right here to study extra.
